originally posted on tumblr, Apr 11th 2026
Movie-A-Day-Thon #47: Vertigo (1958)
There we are, another Hitchcock movie! They show up plenty on my lists, but somehow they keep evading me when I pick them? It's kind of odd. The spirographs are a fun way to background the beginning credits, too!
The exposition does leave some to be desired. "Now we were engaged, weren't we, Midge?" What in the bizarre question?? Either he's being an ass about it, or he's trying to flirt her up - badly. But that No shoulder or back straps brassiere sounds wild, bet it must hurt like hell to wear. Luckily we soon get into the detective plot and things get more interesting.
I do enjoy the museum scene in the stalking montage, they really hammer in the details that you're supposed to take notice of. And the hotel section really was trippy. I do gotta say, something about "the gay old bohemian days of gay old San Francisco" goes so hard. Was there any other time than gay old San Francisco? Sound off in the comments (I do not know much US history, never cared to)!
Yknow I take it back actually, Johnny and Midge have the same sense of flirting finesse, which is none. Girl what were you THINKING with that painting?!
The conclusion at the church museum was well foreshadowed and well managed, but it did so feel a bit too fast. Not in a bad way but in a "wait, just like that?!?" way, you know? I don't know, I never quite liked this older movie's habit of women running away to do whatever the hell whenever they got agitated, and the male lead had to grab them and clutch to them so close and, yes this was sort of a subversion of that expectation but also. Huh??
I've found there are two kinds of movies of 2hrs or more: they either are a chore to get through and you must pay active attention at all times or you will drift off. Or they make supremely good use of their running time and they do not waste your time, energy or investment. GoodFellas for example, was 2 hours long yet I hardly felt those two hours, I was so enraptured by the narrative.
Vertigo is... somewhere in between? I did thoroughly enjoy it, and those 2 hours didn't drag, but there were times where the quiet scenes left my mind wandering more than introspecting and engaging with the movie. And after Madeleine, my interest waned somewhat, reminded me a bit how I felt so derelict after the shower scene in Psycho. Why is the movie still going, why am I still here, what else is left?
Tell you why, another plot explanation and awful case of grief denial I've seen. I know Hitchcock has this thing about telling the audience more than the characters do, so it builds suspense. Well I think in this one instance, we could have done without the reveal at first and then the moment it clicks would have hit like a goddamn truck. We already had the setup for the necklace, the payoff would have been much more potent without the letter interrupting the narrative flow.
And can I say. Bullshit ending. Good movie yeah, but bullshit ending.
No comments:
Post a Comment